I learned this week that one of my exes landed an ultra-fantastic academic humanities job. I mean, a real plum. Ivy. Tenure-track. The whole deal. In this economy.
This provoked a variety of responses.
First response: sheer joy."WOW! That's incredible! He is perfect for that gig, and it is exactly the sort of thing he has always wanted! He has worked so hard, and this validates all of that work! And they took him while still ABD! That is fantastic! Way to go!"
Second response: toxic comparison."We started out at the same time, from the same place, and he's already there, but I'm not. He won more prestigious grants than I did. He is a better teacher than I am. He is smarter than I am. He works harder than I do. He's just better than I am. But I went out and did things. I lived on my own. I traveled around Asia. I speak Chinese. I've designed and taught my own courses as well, and I did it in Beijing. I learned how to rock-climb. I'm better than he is. No, he's better than I am. No, I'm better than he is. AARRGGHH! Which is it?"
Third response: panicked self-denigration. "There are no jobs in my field, and even if there were, I couldn't get one. My CV sucks. I'm not giving enough papers, I don't have anything published, other people are doing 'better' at this than I am. What do I really have to offer that a decent institution would want? Let's go check the job postings right now. And update my CV. Immediately. Eek!"
Fourth response: unbridled envy masquerading as angry blame of self and others. "If my advisor wasn't AWOL, I might actually have gotten some career advice. If both of my advisors hadn't advocated against a museum internship last summer, I would have curatorial experience. If I worked harder, I could have presented more papers. If I was smarter, I would have known about XXX and saved myself time and energy. If I practiced less yoga/listened to fewer podcasts/worked weekends/didn't blog/didn't run/didn't travel/etc., I might have been able to get an article published. If I had focused more on the Ph.D., I might be done by now."
Fifth response: release what does not serve you.Niggling at the back of my head the entire time I was having the above freak-out is the fact that in these situations, comparisons are futile. He works in a different field, in a different region halfway around the world from mine. The situation is completely unrelated. No matter what else I thought, the fact that
the comparison served no purpose whatsoever was there. And if yoga teaches you anything, it is to release what does not serve you.
How to manage emotions when someone you know lands a really great job
1. Accept that you will have strong responses. Those may be
very strong responses, perhaps of the green monster variety. Frustration, fury, despair, maybe even a little bit of depression might strike. Hopefully some joy and awe will be in there too, though.
2. Sit with those responses for a while. Don't verbalize them out loud: maybe in a journal, but not out loud. And definitely not to your colleagues. Sniping and badmouthing are not classy. But let yourself feel those responses, because they might be big and unwieldy.
3. Stop comparing yourself with them. Just stop. Cold turkey.It serves no purpose whatsoever, and frankly there are just too many factors for you to analyze, most of which you'll never even know. There is no other way to do it than to just abruptly stop comparing yourself. No three-step process, just the will to stop.
4.Think about whether your work is your identity, and use your response as a springboard.If it is your identity, and this work is your life's passion, then use this news of someone landing a great gig as a reminder that there
are academic jobs in the humanities available. You know someone with a great job! You could do that, too! Go sit down and do something in that direction - write a bit more, brainstorm a conference paper, update your CV, get in touch with a colleague at another institution to network.
If it is not your identity, think about why. How do you define yourself? Is your work your passion, or does it pay the bills? What else is there in your life that you really feel is "your thing"? Take that knowledge, and move in that direction instead. If you're a runner, go for a run and do it faster than before. If you're a blogger, write a post that is better than your last one. If you're a baker, bake a better cake than your family and friends have enjoyed before. If you're a parent, go teach your kids something new that you know.
Whatever you decide, let the news of a job light a fire under your own backside to propel you forward in the direction you want to go. Not the direction you think you should go, or the direction "society" wants you to take, but
your direction that demonstrates what
your passion is. Go out and do something
right now.
5. Let the person know how thrilled you are for them.Because you are, honestly, thrilled. Not only did they prove it was possible, but they provided you with inspiration to move further along your own passion. Send them an e-mail or give them a call, maybe take them out for a drink. Be genuinely happy for them, because this makes them happy. And we can all be thrilled when someone's hard work pays off.
6. Release what does not serve you.Let it go. Take what is useful from this, and move on in that direction. The lessons are useful; the comparisons are not.
**Have you encountered situations like this? Leave a note in the comments with your experiences and how you managed your emotions when someone landed a job.